Nobody does the girl-next-door thing better than Natalie Portman. So it's no surprise that her eye makeup looks tend to be soft and glowing but not at all obvious or in-your-face. Like this one she wore last night at the Venice Film Festival:
From far away the colors almost blend in with each other, but you can see that's it a bit more complex when you get in closer.
She's got a bit of dark gray liner on her top lids, a light bronze under her eyes and in the inner corners, brown on her upper lids and a touch of peach blended up into her brow bones.
Loving this? Well, you should try it then. Here are some colors that would get the job done: